How can retailers manage Black Friday returns
The retail sector is currently seeing a surge in the number of ‘serial returns’, with an estimated £6.6bn of online returns in 2024, according to the Annual Returns Benchmark Report 2024. However, as we are fast approaching Black Friday, retailers face the risk of dealing with huge numbers of returns once again. In 2023, an estimated one in six fashion purchases made on Black Friday in the UK were returned. Managing these returns efficiently while mitigating associated costs is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction and profitability. This guide covers effective ways to handle returns and exchanges during Black Friday and strategies to reduce costs

Register to get 1 more free article
Reveal the article below by registering for our email newsletter.
Want unlimited access? View Plans
Already have an account? Sign in
Establish a clear returns policy
A well-defined returns policy is the first step to manage customer expectations and minimise confusion, particularly during the high-volume Black Friday period. Retailers should ensure that the policy is straightforward, accessible, and clearly visible on their website, in receipts, and within email confirmations. If retailers plan to change their return policy for Black Friday, it has to be done well before the spike in Black Friday sales.
Providing a flexible but time-bound return window for Black Friday purchases can also accommodate customers while helping retailers manage inventory. Additionally, specifying the eligibility condition required for returns, such as unopened packaging or intact tags, reduces the number of unsellable items, streamlining the process and supporting efficient restocking and cost recovery during the post-Black Friday period.
Invest in return-friendly technology
In order to maintain returns efficiently retailers should have a streamlined, automated process. These systems can streamline returns by instantly scanning and categorising products for resale, refurbishment, or disposal, allowing a faster turnaround.
Integrated tracking systems also give customers real-time updates on their return status, which reduces inquiry volume. Partnering with specialised reverse logistics providers further enhances this efficiency, as they manage logistical complexities on the retailer’s behalf. Utilising technology to simplify returns can also help cut labour and resource costs. Lastly, it also reduces manual errors and saves time during the already busy period.
Form a customer service team
Despite having an automated returns process retailers must also have a customer service team for enhanced customer support during an influx of return inquiries. Preparing customer service teams involves providing comprehensive training on return policies, troubleshooting, and handling high call volumes. Moreover, additional support can be provided via chat bots, email, phone, and social media, which can prevent service bottlenecks. Retailers can also update their FAQ page to help customers find answers independently without relying on live agents.
Offer incentives for exchanges over returns
Offering incentives on product exchanges instead of returns helps retailers retain revenue while keeping customers engaged with the brand. Retailers can offer incentives such as additional credit for exchanges or special discounts for those choosing store credit. This promotes alternatives to refunds and also results in a loyal customer base and repeat purchases. More exchanges mean reduced refund processing costs and more satisfied customers. It also means continued sales even in the post-Black Friday period.
Implement cost-recovery measures for returns
Retailers can offset return costs by implementing targeted cost-recovery measures. For instance, restocking fees on specific items, such as bulky or custom-made products, help cover handling costs without deterring customers from making returns. Eco-friendly returns options, like partnerships with carbon-neutral shipping providers, appeal to environmentally-conscious shoppers while helping reduce costs.
Additionally, offering incentives to customers who commit to “return-free” purchases, such as rewards points or future discounts, can reduce return rates while enhancint customer loyalty. These measures help retailers balance the cost of returns and maintain profitability during the holiday shopping season.
Secure inventory levels
63% of customers prefer to do their holiday shopping online, so high post-holiday return volumes can have a considerable impact on eCommerce supply chains in particular. To prepare for the influx of returns during the holiday season, it is important to secure your inventory levels. This means having enough inventory on hand to meet customer demand, while also being able to quickly process and restock returned products.
Retailers must also take time to make purchasing and production decisions and plan ahead of time which products to promote over Black Friday so that you can stock accordingly. This will help avoid last-minute rush and make sure retailers have enough inventory to meet customer demand. Businesses must then make sure to restock returned products as quickly as possible to get them back into circulation.
Track customer data
A good way for retailers to deal with a huge number of returns during Black Friday, is by taking a look at last year’s Black Friday return data. This will give retailers a good starting point for preparing for this year’s Black Friday returns. Examining key metrics like total return volume, average return value, and common return reasons offers valuable insights into customer behaviour and return trends.
This data-driven approach also helps businesses make informed decisions on inventory management, product selection, and customer service strategies tailored to Black Friday’s demands. By anticipating which products might generate the most returns and understanding the typical reasons behind them, retailers can streamline operations, enhance customer satisfaction, and avoid being overwhelmed with returns.